A Comment on Comments

Since this blog casts an agnostic eye on religion, politics, and existence, it sometimes attracts a lot of comments, some of them quite impassioned.  But many of the longer comments threads have now reached the MEGO stage – “my eyes glaze over” – so it’s time for me to establish some guidelines, be a good [...]

Believing in Peace

“I can’t believe you don’t believe in anything!” someone wrote on this blog a while back, commenting on my agnosticism (actually, she used capital letters and lots of exclamation marks, but I’ll refrain).   And I was a bit shocked by that.  What kind of human being can I claim to be if I don’t believe [...]

An Agnostic Manifesto: Part One

For the last two weeks, I’ve been deeply engaged in what I know to be a futile pursuit.   It’s called writing:  in this case, part of the biography of Muhammad I’m working on.   Specifically, this agnostic Jew has been trying to ‘understand’ the pivotal gnostic moment of Islam – what happened the night on Mount [...]

The 100th Post: a Non-Mission Statement

The tyranny of round numbers has me in its grip.  A decade birthday or a centennial seems to insist on comment, whether we are ready for it or not.   Usually not. Today my ‘dashboard’ informs me that this is the one-hundredth post since I began The Accidental Theologist nine months ago (note how I even [...]

The ‘Obvious’

You’ll find none of the comfort of received opinion here. No claim to truth, let alone Truth (that capital T always makes me nervous).  None of that astounding confidence (aka hubris) that cloaks ignorance and prejudice.  The aim is to question, to explore, to keep my mind — and yours — open, raise some sparks, [...]

Faith, Falsehood, and Fiction

Here’s Peruvian writer Mario Vargas Llosa, the newly crowned Nobel literature laureate and a proud agnostic, talking about truth, lies, and fiction in a piece called “Is Fiction the Art of Living?“: THE lies in novels are not gratuitous – they fill in the insufficiencies of life. Thus, when life seems full and absolute, and [...]

Delicious Ignorance

Okay, so it’s hard not to crow in ironic delight about this one:  turns out atheists and agnostics score higher than religious Americans on a test of religious knowledge.  Howzat for un-believable! A new survey released by the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life shows that one of the most deeply religious countries in [...]

Wagering on Peace

Is it rational to believe that peace is possible in the Middle East?  Sometimes it seems not.   A good friend in New York, a long-time Middle East peace activist, confided that the Israeli use of deadly force against the Gaza-bound flotilla had brought her close to despair.   Yet historian Tony Judt in an op-ed today [...]

The Insult of Oil

Every few months, there’s a minor oil spill on Seattle’s Lake Union – a boat’s bilge pump goes haywire, or a fuel line leaks.  I wake with a headache, the houseboat full of fumes.  Outside, the water around my raft is an iridescent swirl of red and green and yellow and purple, glinting maliciously in [...]

Kaddish for my Mother

The day we bury my mother, the rabbi surprises me.  He asks if I’d like to lead the Kaddish prayer alongside my brother. He’s new to this orthodox Anglo-Jewish congregation, but perhaps he’s heard of “the scene” I made at my father’s grave thirteen years ago.  In insult at being excluded when the shovel was [...]

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 237 other followers