Blog


About


Books

 Latest Post: Flash!

Agnostic
A Spirited Manifesto
Available April 4, 2016

   Who is the AT?   Books by LH
  • Agnostic

  • The First Muslim

  • After The Prophet

  • Jezebel

  • Mary

  • More from LH

     

The Taming of Jesus

Posted July 27th, 2013 by Lesley Hazleton

'Zealot'“A tough-minded, deeply political book” — my review in the San Francisco Chronicle of Reza Aslan’s best-selling ‘Zealot: The Life and Times of Jesus of Nazareth‘

‘Zealot’?  A biography of Jesus could have no more provocative title.  But it turns out to be the perfect one for Reza Aslan’s unearthing (or should that be un-heavening?) of “the Jesus before Christianity.”  As he cogently demonstrates, the real Jesus — the radical Jew who preached, agitated, and was executed for his pains — was a far more complex figure than many Christians care to acknowledge.

The zeal in question is both religious and political.  At a time when this kind of zealotry is associated predominantly with Islamic extremists, it’s fascinating to see similar processes at work in first-century Jewish Palestine, which was occupied territory – occupied, that is, by the Romans.  In opposition, messianic nationalist movements created what Aslan aptly describes as “zealous warriors of God who would cleanse the land of all foreigners and idolaters.”

This is the historical and political context Jesus was born into, one that takes us beyond the Christ figure created by his followers after his death to the actual man, “a revolutionary swept up, as all Jews of his era were, in religious and political turmoil.”

Given that turmoil, it should come as no surprise that “the Jesus of history had a far more complex attitude toward violence” than is usually assumed.  Gentle shepherds don’t have much place here.  Aslan reads the admonitions to love your enemies and turn the other cheek as directed toward relationships between Jews, not between Jews and foreigners, and especially not between Jews and occupiers.  “The message was one of repossessing the land,“ he writes, “a movement of national liberation for the afflicted and oppressed.”  A kingdom, that is, very much of this world, not another.

This historical territory has been explored before, by biblical scholars such as Richard Horsley and Dominic Crossan.  But in Aslan’s hands, it gains broader resonance.  He brings to bear his expertise in the volatile territory of politics and religion (his earlier book Beyond Fundamentalism analyzed the root causes of militant religious extremism) as well as his deep background as a scholar of religion, renowned especially for the most readable history of Islam yet written, No god But God.

As in those earlier books, not only does he get the full picture, but he can also write – sometimes irresistibly, as when he drops into a kind of tongue-in-cheek interfaith slang, mentioning Herod’s “nebbish sons,” for instance, and Herod himself as “King of the Jews, no less!”

But cherished legends, watch out.  Aslan can be scathingly dismissive of such episodes as Salome dancing for John the Baptist’s head, or Pontius Pilate’s interrogation of Jesus.  Prepare for words like “nonsense” and “fairy tale” as he traces what holds up historically (and geographically), and what’s been elided, even deliberately disguised, in the gospel accounts.  Which is not to blame the gospel writers.  Aslan points out that the concept of empirically valid historical reality is a relatively modern one.  “It would have been an altogether foreign concept to the gospel writers, for whom history was not a matter of uncovering facts, but of revealing truths.”

Perhaps the most fascinating part of Zealot, then, is the analysis of how Jesus was tamed by his own followers, and why.  Soon after his death, the early Jesus movement split between the “Hebrews” who stayed in Jerusalem under James’ leadership, and the Hellenists abroad led by Paul.  The bitter infighting between them would be resolved by force majeure:  the disastrous failure of the Jewish rebellion against Rome, which led to the torching of Jerusalem in the year 70 and the expulsion of surviving Jews from what remained of the city.  With the ‘Hebrew’ faction thus in disarray, the Hellenist appeal of Paul’s Christianity won out, and Jesus’ specifically Jewish revolutionary fervor would be toned down to suit a much larger audience:  the Roman empire itself.

This entailed absolving the Romans from responsibility for the crucifixion, instead blaming the unruly (and unrulable) Jews, and thus laying the basis for two millennia of Christian anti-Semitism. Where the early Jesus movement was Jewish, Christianity would now be anything but.  As Aslan notes, the gospels are, in this sense, a radical break with history – a wiping out of the specific past to be replaced by a universal future.

Yet Zealot itself is testament to the fact that they didn’t quite succeed.  Aslan’s insistence on human and historical actuality turns out to be far more interesting than dogmatic theology, and certainly more intriguing and exciting for any modern reader not piously devoted to the idea of gospel truth.  This tough-minded, deeply political book does full justice to the real Jesus, and honors him in the process.

(Seattle:  I’ll be talking about the book with Reza Aslan in the auditorium of the downtown Central Library on Monday July 29, 7-8.30 pm.  Free admission.)

Share this post:  Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail
File under: Christianity, Judaism, messianism | Tagged: Tags: 'Zealot', Christ, gospels, life of Jesus, review, Reza Aslan, San Francisco Chronicle, Seattle Public Library | 9 Comments
  1. Sohail Kizilbash says:
    July 27, 2013 at 9:51 am

    Thank you Lesley for the review. It seems to be a very interesting book.

    Annemarie Schimmel said in one of her books that, it does not matter what the fact was, what matters is, what people believe in. I suppose 3 billion plus people will continue to believe what they have been told for the last 2,000 years.

  2. Jerry M says:
    July 28, 2013 at 10:37 am

    I was watching a fox news interview with him and I was surprised at how ignorant the interviewer was. For a US writer who writes on religion and who already wrote a book on Islam, it would be a surprise for him not to tackle Christianity.

  3. Matthew Melle Johnson says:
    July 28, 2013 at 5:44 pm

    Reblogged this on Von Melee.

  4. Nancy McClelland says:
    July 29, 2013 at 7:34 pm

    Jerry, I saw the same interview — buzzfeed was pretty astonished by it as well:
    http://www.buzzfeed.com/andrewkaczynski/is-this-the-most-embarrassing-interview-fox-news-has-ever-do

  5. danielabdalhayymoore says:
    July 31, 2013 at 4:05 pm

    Greetings:
    Please excuse me, Lesley, if this has been covered, as I haven’t quite managed to read through every email here (your About page). But I am wondering if you have been interrogated as thoroughly (credentials, etc.) by the “western media” regarding your book on the Prophet Muhammad (salallahu alayhi wa sallam) as heavily as Reza Aslan has on this book of his on (the prophet) Jesus (alayhi wa sallam). It occurred to me to ask this, having read and found certainly thought-provoking your fine book on the Shi’a split, and on Muhammad, and having viewed a good interviewer talking with him from Huffington Post, and read about the Fox interviewer, who (without viewing it) seems to have been less so. Have you been put on the defensive at all?

    • Lesley Hazleton says:
      July 31, 2013 at 6:06 pm

      Oh yes. Not as publicly, and not by “western media,” but some conservative Muslims have made it clear that for them, my Jewishness is as suspicious as Reza’s Muslimness is to Fox News. Basically they ask the same question: what made you, as a Muslim/Jew, write about Jesus/Muhammad. And behind that question, first, a challenge as to your “right” to do so, and second, the assumption of an “agenda” — in Reza’s case, anti-Christian, in my case, anti-Muslim. On the other hand, many thinking Muslims have welcomed The First Muslim, as you’ll see if you scroll through comments on posts about the book, just as many thinking Christians have welcomed Reza’s book. Humanizing history doesn’t undermine faith, as conservatives seem to imagine; both Jesus and Muhammad are not less but more remarkable when seen in their lived context and experience.
      I’ll be posting at greater length about all this very soon.

      • Nancy McClelland says:
        July 31, 2013 at 11:16 pm

        What an excellent and humble response to an honest and obvious question. Kudos to you both.

  6. milons says:
    September 7, 2013 at 4:56 pm

    It’s a shame you have to entertain comments from some of my bone-headed co-religionists, who can’t see past your Jewishness. They tend to define themselves against what they’re not as to opposed to what they are and have done a fine job of covering beauty with filth. It reminds me of the Month Python sketch about the Spanish Inquisition.

    • Lesley Hazleton says:
      September 7, 2013 at 6:19 pm

      Vive Monty Python!

Libraries Under Threat

Posted July 23rd, 2012 by Lesley Hazleton

I’m reviewing copy-editing of the new book, which means I’m spending most of my days swearing at the copy-editor and typing STET hundreds of times over. Meanwhile there’s an election coming up in Seattle, and on the ballot is a levy for the public library. That should be a shoo-in for such a book-proud city, right? No excuse not to keep my nose to the grindstone.

Wrong. Critics of the levy, including the Seattle Times, are talking out both sides of their mouths. You know: “Of course we support the library but…”

But? There’s a “but” to supporting the library? Apparently so. The city, says the august Times editorial board, should pay for increased costs out of its budget, and a levy is the wrong way to pay. Which in principle is true, and in practice is bullshit. If the Times has its way and the levy doesn’t pass, part of Seattle’s great system of branch libraries will be closed.

So I just emailed this to every Seattleite in my address book along with a plea to vote. If you have any Seattleites in your address book, feel free to forward:

“My branch.” It’s personal. I can go to any other branch, of course, or to Rem Koolhaas’ magnificent downtown landmark, but my branch is part of my everyday life, part of my neighborhood. It’s where I belong.

It’s where books are held for me, slips marked HAZL sticking out of them, making me happy each time I see them waiting on the shelf: “For me!”  It’s where I wait in line with uncharacteristic patience as five-year-olds laboriously check out a dozen books at a time. It’s where I pick up inter-library loan books, each in its peach-colored wrapper with dire warnings not to bend, mark, or mutilate, and always look first to see how far they’ve come to reach me: Oregon, Kansas, even all the way across country from Massachusetts. It’s where the librarians know me, and I them, and where I’m now advocating for the “recommended books” shelf to be reinstated. I like knowing that my librarians have good taste.

“My branch”: one small building devoted to the life of the mind, and to the egalitarianism of that life, regardless of how much you earn or don’t earn. If I had to pay for every book I read, I’d be a pauper several times over by now.  The library is what keeps me alive. No wonder my spirits lift every time I walk up the steps.

But for how much longer? If this levy does not pass, the residents of at least three neighborhoods are going to be deprived of that sense of “my branch.”   I may be one of them. You may be one of them.

I know if it happens to me, I will mourn. Something essential will be gone, ripped away by selfishness and indifference. My everyday life will be changed. Seattle will be changed. It’s not just me who’ll be the poorer for it, and not just you either; it’s all of us.

Share this post:  Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail
File under: existence, sanity | Tagged: Tags: branch libraries, closings, levy, Proposition 1, Rem Koolhaas, Seattle Public Library, Seattle Times | 3 Comments
  1. Lynn Rosen says:
    July 28, 2012 at 6:03 pm

    Darling. Although I don’t live in Seattle and have no vote on the matter, your heartfelt plea for the continuation of a critical system dear to my heart goes noted and shared.

  2. pah says:
    August 9, 2012 at 9:29 am

    in Toronto Canada, the same thing will probably happen.
    Fortunately my local library is still not up for closure.
    i personally can;t live without it, i go twice a week, visit the local bookstores, write down the name of any book i want and then get it from the library (ordered on the computer, no less!) it is a brillian, amazing library.
    sorry i;m also not a Seattlian, but when talk of libraries closing down starts, my heart goes into overdrive. all the best

    • Lesley Hazleton says:
      August 10, 2012 at 3:40 pm

      Your good wishes worked, and the levy was approved! Huge relief. I was away all week (having voted early by mail, of course), so forgive the late update. Hope Toronto-ites (-ians?) prove as sane as Seattleites.– L.

Order the Book

Available online from:
  • Amazon.com
  • Barnes & Noble
  • IndieBound
  • Powell's
Or from your favorite bookseller.

Tag Cloud

absurd agnosticism art atheism Buddhism Christianity ecology existence feminism fundamentalism Islam Judaism light Middle East sanity technology ugliness US politics war women

Recent Posts

  • Flash! September 1, 2019
  • “What’s Wrong With Dying?” February 9, 2017
  • The Poem That Stopped Me Crying December 30, 2016
  • Talking About Soul at TED December 5, 2016
  • ‘Healing’? No Way. November 10, 2016
  • Psychopath, Defined August 2, 2016
  • Lovely NYT Review of ‘Agnostic’! July 14, 2016
  • Playing With Stillness June 22, 2016
  • Inside Palestine June 20, 2016
  • Virtual Unreality June 6, 2016
  • The Free-Speech Challenge May 23, 2016
  • Category-Free April 20, 2016
  • Staring At The Void April 13, 2016
  • Sherlock And Me April 3, 2016
  • Hard-Wired? Really? March 22, 2016
  • A Quantum Novel March 9, 2016
  • This Pre-Order Thing March 4, 2016
  • The Agnostic Celebration February 29, 2016
  • The First Two Pages February 23, 2016
  • Two Thumbs-Up For “Agnostic” February 10, 2016
Skip to toolbar
  • About WordPress
    • WordPress.org
    • Documentation
    • Support Forums
    • Feedback