I’m still thinking about a single word from a movie I saw last month — a difficult, transcendent movie about love. Real love.
Amour is not an easy film, and it’s certainly not for anyone who’s afraid of ageing, let alone anyone nurturing fantasies of immortality. Written and directed by the hard-edged Michael Haneke, it’s about a loving, companiable couple in their early eighties, played by two veterans of the French new wave: Emmanuelle Riva (Alain Resnais’ classic Hiroshima Mon Amour) and Jean-Louis Trintignant (Claude Lelouch’s A Man and a Woman). And it’s about what happens when she has a stroke — a relatively minor one — and then another, devastating one…
I saw it at a small private screening, and thought it beautiful — quietly courageous, uncommonly real, and truly loving in a way that goes so far beyond Hollywood stereotypes as to make them hollow caricatures of humanity. So I was quite dismayed when others there called it depressing. It was too long, they said. It made them uncomfortable. It dwelled too much on the small details of life. It took far too long it took to arrive at its inevitable denouement.
All these things were part of what made me admire the movie so. And why I went home convinced that it would win no awards.
What a delight to be so very wrong! Though I didn’t yet know it, Amour had already won the Palme d’Or at Cannes, and was now being talked about as the front-runner for the best foreign-film Oscar (thus the private screening copy) — talk that ramped up this past weekend when it won the Los Angeles Film Critics Award for best picture of 2012. The Oscars might actually redeem themselves this year.
But what’s stuck with me ever since I saw the movie — and the reason I’ll see it again — is one seemingly simple detail in the couple’s everyday life:
Whenever one does something for the other, even something as minor as putting a cup of coffee on the table or taking the empty cup to the sink, the other says “Merci.”
That’s it — a simple thank you. Said not automatically, but not with great stress either. Said quietly, but appreciatively. “You mean it was polite,” someone said. But no, that was not at all what I meant. This was far more than mere politeness (I grew up in England, so I know how shallow politeness can be): this was courteous. Real courtesy: an acknowledgment of the other’s existence — of the small kindnesses and fond accommodations that make up the couple’s daily life together. It was, in a beautiful phrase I heard over the dinner table just last night, part of “the rhythm of connection.”
The word is said, in its quiet, companiable way, many times before the second stroke deprives the wife of speech. So it hovers in the air, unsaid, when she can no longer speak. In the end, when her husband finally brings himself to do what he knows she wants him to do, I found myself saying thank you for her.
I don’t want to act the spoiler, so I won’t spell it out for you. Enough to say that yes, death can be a courtesy all its own. And as it happened, I thought “Yes, that’s real love.”
Great review of a film that i have heard great things about and cannot wait to see. One minor niggle that did bother me and kind of spolit the review for me personally was ….”(I grew up in England, so I know how shallow politeness can be)”…… being several generations British and being British born and bred i had politeness drummed into me by my very Victorian like parents……being polite was a sign of breeding and good manners, and showed courtesy to other people. Seeing in today’s society i have noticed a distinct lack of good manners…..if you do get politeness from someone in Great Britain it was because they were raised in a good way to show manners to other people and not because they are being shallow.
Ah, but that’s exactly the differentiation I was trying to make — between having “politeness drummed into you,” as you put it, and a deeper, more genuine appreciation of others. Between good manners, that is, and real connection between individuals.
That said, you make a good point: Social politeness, from a check-out clerk’s “Have a nice day” to a quick “Sorry” at having accidentally jostled someone in a crowded subway or nearly poked them in the eye with an umbrella, is vital to the quality of civic life — but really only appreciated when it’s said in such a way that makes you feel it’s genuine.
Dear Ms Hazleton. I loved this piece of writing so much, I couldn’t help spread the word. So I translated this article into Turkish and posted it today in my blog here: http://birtekask.blogspot.ch/2012/12/misafir-yazar-leslie-hazleton.html
I gave proper credit to you saying that this was written by you and published in your blog on December 11. There are also two links to your blog.
Please let me know if you agree with this. If not, I will delete it immediately.
(Can’t wait to read the First Muslim…)
Kind regards,
Hande
Hande — but of course! Re-posting something I’ve written, with acknowledgment, is a high compliment. Taking the time and care to translate it first: an even higher compliment. Letting me know: a lovely courtesy. Thank you — Lesley
Thank you for writing this and everything else you write. I am very much inspired by your passion to communicate.
Will be following…
Lesley, I had to translate this following statement to you; I liked it so much… It is a comment to my blog about your article. A friend says “Thank you so much for introducing Lesley Hazleton to me. I was first intrigued by her article, then her books and her TED talk. I listened. Her voice, her expression, her talent in communication… I loved it! It is as if she hand-picks the words, dives into them to discover the real meanings, and offers them to us. I cannot wait to get her books. I also wrote to her. Thank you again very much.
Thank you both. Much appreciated. — L.
Dear Ms Hazleton,I am very gratefull to Hande to present you to me.I read some of your writings and listened your Ted talkings.loved them
.I want to write so many things but I will only say THANK YOU.Because you know the meanings of “a simple thank you”.I will also try to read your books.
Best regards,figen